One moment that really stood out to me in Frankenstein was
when Victor Frankenstein found that his closest friend, Henry Clerval, had been
killed by his own creation. I remember reading the pages before he finds out about
Clerval’s death and wondering what the real significance was to the story. Why
was Shelley going into such great detail about this random small town that Victor
went to and why were its inhabitants so suspicious of him and so inhospitable
towards him? Was it really necessary to discuss this one detour Frankenstein
took? What were the odds that Frankenstein would have to deal with yet another
horrible situation? I was clearly being too naïve and optimistic about
Frankenstein’s situation. I remember then feeling filled with dread as I
realized this town’s tragedy probably did have some significance to the story
and to Frankenstein himself, obviously. I began to wonder about who would
suffer next, but I did not ever suspect that Frankenstein would have to face
such a tragic loss or that Clerval had been murdered by the monster. I
suspected that maybe Frankenstein looked like the criminal the town was after
and would merely be placed in jail for a little while. I wondered if possibly
some random man who looked like he would have been associated with Frankenstein
but who actually had no connection to him whatsoever had been murdered. I
thought that maybe the monster had killed an innocent man who could not bear to
look at his demonic face and was killed because of his fears. I was again being
far too optimistic, but how was I to know that such horrible events were about
to occur! I just didn’t want this poor man to have to suffer any more, as
childish as that sounds. I honestly was moved most by this scene because I
genuinely felt bad for Victor. Victor says in the book, "The human frame
could no longer support the agonizing suffering that I endured" (Shelley
122). It was at this point in the book that I myself could no longer endure the
horrific amount of suffering this one man faced. I felt a new sense of sympathy
towards Victor. Clerval had been such a central figure in his life and was one
whom he even considered a part of his family. I could not even begin to imagine
the amount of pain he must have been in after finding him dead. I also felt
that this moment began a huge shift in the book. Although Frankenstein had been
depressed before, now he truly wanted to be dead. I could only hope that
the next chapters would be happier, but I now knew that this one sad man would
never truly feel happiness again.
I don't think it sounds childish at all to say that we emotionally identify with a character who has gone through so much pain that we instinctively hope that his suffering is finally over. In this case, the fact that the plot instead takes a twist which does just the opposite, intensifying his suffering to a previously unimaginable degree. So I think you've made a good choice and described your reactions to that moment very well.
ReplyDelete